Fine Grain Tool Steel, Held to a 4:1 Forging Ratio and a Written Annealing Curve

EFS is the grain refining regime we run on our hot work, cold work and plastic mould grades. Two controlled operations produce it, both on our own presses and our own bogie hearth furnaces, and both signed off before anything ships.

Minimum forging ratio 4 : 1

Heavier sections start from a larger ingot, so the ratio itself never has to move. Our ingot range of 3 to 12 tonnes exists for exactly that.

  • Nineteen years
  • 100+ countries
  • Grain size and carbide distribution rated on your heat, in an EN 10204 3.1 MTC

Fine Grain Tool Steel Grades

Thirteen of the fourteen grades we produce run the EFS regime, across three families. M2 is a high speed steel and is supplied outside that regime, on the same melting, electroslag, inspection and certification route.

Order in the designation your customer uses. Equivalents are one grade here, quoted once and certified once, with cross-references to AISI, DIN and W-Nr, JIS, GB, ASSAB and BÖHLER confirmed in writing on the first reply so you can forward the mapping.

5Hot work
5Cold work
3Plastic mould
Sawn end faces of fine grain tool steel round bar in four diameters, colour-marked by heat
Bar ends from four heats, colour-marked before dispatch.
Fourteen tool steel grades, their equivalents, family and EFS regime status
GradeAlso calledFamilyEFS regime
H131.2344, SKD61Hot workYes
1.2367—Hot workYes
H111.2343Hot workYes
H101.2365Hot workYes
1.2714—Hot work, forging diesYes
D21.2379, SKD11Cold workYes
DC53—Cold workYes
D31.2080Cold workYes
D61.2436Cold workYes
O11.2510Cold work, oil hardeningYes
1.2316—Plastic mould, corrosion resistantYes
1.2085—Plastic mould, pre-hardenedYes
4201.2083, 3Cr17Plastic mould, mirror finishYes
M21.3343High speedSupplied outside EFS
Hot work, cold work and plastic mould tool steel racked in three separate bays

EFS Effects Inside the Bar

Three things come out of the regime: high cleanliness, uniform grain size through the section, and toughness at the level European tool steel buyers work to.

Cleanliness is set upstream, in our own melting and electroslag shops, and the EFS regime works on what that ingot delivers. Reduction under the press breaks up the as-cast structure and the carbide banding that solidification leaves behind. The controlled annealing curve that follows fixes the grain size and the carbide morphology at delivery. What your customer receives is a bar produced to a written regime for that grade, repeatable on the next heat and the one after it.

  • Same response to hardening

    A uniform structure responds the same way from bar to bar and batch to batch, so the hardness that comes back from the tool room furnace lands where their route says it should.

  • More predictable distortion

    Distortion is easier to predict when carbides are distributed rather than banded, which matters most on cold work sections that get through-hardened and ground afterwards.

  • Edge and polish

    Finer, more evenly distributed carbides take a better edge on cutting and blanking tools, and polish more evenly on the plastic mould grades.

Where our part ends

These are material properties of the structure we deliver in the annealed condition. Hardening, tempering and finishing happen in your customer's shop, on their route, so the numbers that end up in the finished tool come from that process working on our structure.

As-cast carbide banding on the left, redistributed carbides after reduction and annealing on the right As cast After 4:1 and the anneal Eutectic carbide network laid down on solidification Broken up by deformation, fixed by the cooling rate
Schematic. The rating for your heat is measured, not drawn.
Macro-etched end face of a fine grain tool steel round bar under laboratory light
Polished plastic mould steel plate face showing an even structure across the width

Forging Ratio and Ingot Size

The number the regime controls, and the number that moves instead when the section gets heavier.

The minimum forging ratio we hold is 4:1. It is issued per grade and per section by our metallurgical and process engineers, before the order reaches the shop floor, together with the ingot size the bar is to be started from.

Why the ratio is the number we control

Reduction is what does the work. An as-cast ingot has a coarse solidification structure and, in the high carbon high chromium grades, eutectic carbide banding laid down as it froze. Deformation under the press is what breaks that structure down and redistributes those carbides. The forging ratio is the measure of how much deformation the bar has actually had, which is why it is the number the regime controls rather than the press tonnage or the number of passes.

Ingot → delivered section

When the section gets heavier, what changes is the ingot, not the ratio.

What moves when the section gets heavier

Heavier sections are started from a larger ingot so the same reduction is still available at the end of the route. Our ingot range of 3 to 12 tonnes exists for that, poured in our own two 15-tonne induction furnaces and remelted in our own electroslag shop before it ever reaches a press. Because the ingot is ours to choose, the ratio does not have to move to make a big diameter.

For you, the result is that a 600 mm round and a 60 mm round of the same grade come out of the same regime and land in the same rating band. Your customer's hardening route behaves the same way on both, and you are not managing two different materials under one grade name.

What the engineer issues, before anything is heated

The grade
Which of the thirteen fine grain tool steel grades the order is, and therefore which annealing curve will follow the press.
The section
The finished round or plate size, which decides the forging line and is checked against the range that line covers.
The ingot
Which size out of the 3 to 12 tonne range the bar starts from, chosen so that 4:1 is still available once the section is reached.
A cross-section reduced four to one: the ingot section on the left, the delivered section on the right Ingot section Delivered section Area 4 Area 1 3 to 12 t ingot, poured and remelted here Ratio fixed at 4:1 minimum, ingot chosen to suit
Cross-sectional area, schematic. The ratio is issued per grade and per section.
Fast forging press taking a bite out of a glowing fine grain tool steel billet Electroslag remelted ingots of three sizes staged beside the forging bay
Sawn end of a heavy fine grain tool steel round forged from a twelve tonne ingot
A heavy round is a bigger ingot, not a smaller ratio.

A zero-cost check on any mill you are comparing

Ask what ingot a 600 mm round in your grade is started from, and what reduction that gives. A mill that buys its ingots in can name a diameter and a delivery date. The ingot size sits in someone else's melt shop, which is where that decision was made.

Forging Lines and Section Ranges

Send a section and three answers come back: which line, which ingot, what reduction.

  • Round Ø 300 – 600 mm
    2,500 t fast forging pressTop of the 3 – 12 t ingot range
  • Flat and plate 200 – 500 mm thick, 400 – 1200 mm wide
    2,500 t fast forging pressTop of the 3 – 12 t ingot range
  • Round Ø 150 – 350 mm
    1,600 t fast forging pressMid range
  • Flat and plate 20 – 250 mm thick, 200 – 800 mm wide
    1,600 t fast forging pressMid range
  • Round Ø 16 – 150 mm
    Radial precision forging machineLower range

Three forging lines run on two shifts, and fifty-two people work on them. The radial precision forging machine holds the small diameters, and it is also what sets dimensional accuracy and surface on Ø 16 to 150 mm, so small sections are forged to size rather than turned down from something larger.

Who signs what, in what order

Metallurgical engineer
Issues the regime for that grade and section, before the order reaches the floor.
Production scheduling
Books the line the section belongs on, and owns the date.
Quality
Releases the material against the regime, and holds the release until it reads inside.
The 2,500 tonne fast forging press working a heavy tool steel section
Heavy sections, top of the ingot range.
Radial precision forging machine drawing down a small diameter tool steel round Bundle of small diameter fine grain tool steel rounds forged to size
Ø 16 to 150 mm, forged to size rather than turned down.

The Annealing Regime

Forging sets the structure. The annealing curve is what fixes it.

Eight bogie hearth furnaces run the annealing area. Each has a chamber of 6,000 by 2,000 by 1,500 mm and takes a 30 tonne load, and a cycle runs about three days. Chamber temperature uniformity is held to plus or minus 5 °C, which is what keeps the whole load on the same curve rather than the bars nearest the burners running ahead of the bars in the middle.

The curve itself is written per grade by the same engineers who issue the forging ratio. After the soak, the load is cooled under control at no more than 20 °C per hour down below 600 °C before the furnace can be opened. That cooling rate is the part of the regime that decides carbide morphology and the machinability of the bar your customer puts on the mill, and it is the reason a load stays in the furnace for days rather than hours.

Heat treatment
Twenty-six people work the annealing and quench and temper area.
Written since 2016
The annealing regimes have been written documents since 2016, the year the electroslag shop reached ten furnaces and the EFS regimes stopped being carried in the heads of individual furnace men.
Records
Production and inspection records, including the furnace record for your load, are held for ten years.
Pre-hardened route
The quench and temper line, with two pit furnaces 4,000 mm deep and 1,600 mm in diameter, is what produces 1.2085 and 420 in the pre-hardened condition.
Annealing cycle: soak on the written curve, controlled cool at no more than 20 degrees Celsius per hour to below 600 degrees, then the furnace may be opened Temp Time 600 °C Soak, per grade ≤ 20 °C / h Furnace may be opened One cycle, about three days
Schematic. The curve is issued per grade by our metallurgical and process engineers.
Furnace control panel holding an annealing load on the written curve
Row of bogie hearth annealing furnaces in the heat treatment area Charge car carrying a thirty tonne load of tool steel bar into an annealing furnace
Pit furnace and quench tank on the pre-hardened tool steel line

Annealed Hardness Windows

Delivered hardness is the check that the annealing regime ran as written.

Delivered hardness windows by grade
GradeDelivered conditionHardness
H13, H11, H10, 1.2367Annealed≤ 235 HB
1.2714Annealed≤ 250 HB
D2, D3, D6, DC53Annealed≤ 255 HB
O1Annealed≤ 220 HB
1.2316, 420Annealed≤ 245 HB
M2Annealed≤ 269 HB
1.2085Pre-hardened29 to 33 HRC
420Pre-hardened30 to 34 HRC

Hardness is measured on our own Rockwell and Brinell testers and reported on the certificate for your heat.

Inside the window
Quality signs the certificate for that heat and the material moves. The reading goes on the document you forward.
Outside the window
The heat is re-annealed and re-tested. It is not released and there is no concession shipment. Quality holds the release, and the material only moves once it reads inside the window.
Brinell hardness tester reading an annealed tool steel sample Hardness check bench with annealed tool steel samples from one heat
Rockwell and Brinell, on our own testers.

Structure Ratings on Your Certificate

Every batch ships with an EN 10204 3.1 Material Test Certificate. Two lines on it report what the EFS regime produced in your material.

Grain size rating
Measured on a sample taken from your heat, under one of two metallurgical microscopes.
Carbide distribution rating
Rated on the same sample, on the same heat, by the same laboratory.

Where the numbers come from

A sample is cut from the heat and prepared on our metallography sample line, then rated under one of two metallurgical microscopes by the eight people who staff the physical and chemical laboratory and the metallography room. That is step seven and step eight of the eight-step inspection every heat goes through before quality signs the certificate.

Metallography sample preparation line where fine grain tool steel samples are mounted and polished

How to read them

Both numbers are measured on that heat, so they move from heat to heat with the material. What you are reading is a measurement of the steel in front of you, taken on the sample that came out of it.

  1. Read the heat number at the top of the certificate.
  2. Match it to the marking on the bars you received.
  3. Read the two structure lines under that heat number.
Metallurgical microscope station where grain size and carbide distribution are rated

What the document carries

Five results sit on one document, under one heat number, issued by an authorised inspection representative in our quality department.

  • Chemical analysis
  • Hardness
  • 100% UT to SEP 1921 D/d or E/e
  • Grain size rating
  • Carbide distribution rating
Certification desk in the quality department where an EN 10204 3.1 MTC is issued

Ask for a Sample EN 10204 3.1 MTC

Name a grade you buy and a real certificate comes back, structure lines and all, within 24 hours on a working day.

Request the Sample Certificate
13 of 14Grades on the EFS regime
4 : 1Minimum forging ratio
± 5 °CAnnealing chamber uniformity
10 yearsRecords held per heat

EFS After Electroslag Remelting

Melting sets the composition on our own spectrometers. Electroslag remelting then rebuilds the ingot through a layer of molten slag, taking sulphur and non-metallic inclusions out and giving a solidification pattern that a conventionally cast ingot does not have. All fourteen grades go through our ten electroslag furnaces, and the arithmetic behind that word is set out on our ESR tool steel refining page.

Forging and annealing follow, and that is where the EFS regime is executed. Cleanliness comes from the melt route; grain size and carbide distribution come from reduction and the annealing curve.

Where each property is set

  1. 01 MeltComposition set here
  2. 02 ElectroslagCleanliness set here
  3. 03 Forge4:1 minimum, per section
  4. 04 AnnealCurve written per grade
Electroslag remelted ingot moved from the remelting shop toward the forging bay
The regime starts on an electroslag remelted ingot, never on an as-cast one.

Grain Structure by Grade Family

The regime targets something different in each family, which is why the ratio and the curve are issued per grade rather than as one house setting.

  • Heavy hot work die block in fine grain tool steel, machined on six faces Hot work

    Toughness through a thick die block

    In H13, 1.2367, H11, H10 and 1.2714 the structure question is toughness in heavy sections that are cycled hot and cold. These are the grades most often ordered in the upper part of our diameter range, where holding 4:1 depends on starting from a larger ingot. Grain size uniformity from surface to core is what keeps the response to hardening the same across a thick block.

    • H13
    • 1.2367
    • H11
    • H10
    • 1.2714
    H13 grade data
  • Ground cold work tool steel flat bar stacked for a blanking die order Cold work

    Breaking up the eutectic carbide network

    In D2, DC53, D3, D6 and O1 the structure question is carbide banding. These grades solidify with a coarse eutectic carbide network, and reduction is what breaks it up and redistributes it. In D2 we also hold chromium to 11.0 to 12.0 per cent inside the 1.2379 range, a composition decision made in our own melt shop rather than an inherited one, and it works with the reduction rather than against it. Distortion in hardening and edge behaviour in blanking both track the carbide picture, and D2 buyers can have a hardening test sample taken from the same heat.

    • D2
    • DC53
    • D3
    • D6
    • O1
    D2 grade data
  • Plastic mould steel plate under polish, showing an even surface across the thickness Plastic mould

    An even structure polishes evenly

    In 1.2316, 1.2085 and 420 the structure question is uniformity through the thickness of a plate that will be cavity-machined and then polished. A banded structure shows the bands on the polished surface. 1.2085 and 420 also come pre-hardened, which puts the structure through the quench and temper line as well.

    • 1.2316
    • 1.2085
    • 420

Fine Grain Tool Steel Sizes

Round bar
Ø 16 to 600 mm
Flat bar and plate
20 to 500 mm thick, 200 to 1200 mm wide
Delivery condition
Annealed as standard; 1.2085 and 420 also available pre-hardened
Black forged
Peeled
Ground
Milled six faces
We sell to distributors, stockholders and wholesalers, and we do not retail to tool rooms, so we are not selling to the customers you sell to.
A first order can be a trial to verify the material before it becomes regular replenishment. Stock coverage and dispatch windows are on our homepage.
Fine grain tool steel round bar and plate racked across the full supplied size range
One regime across the whole band, from Ø 16 to Ø 600 mm.
Four tool steel surface finishes side by side: black forged, peeled, ground and milled
Four surfaces, quoted per line rather than per order.
Bundled fine grain tool steel staged for dispatch with heat marking visible

Send the Grade and the Section

You get the route, the ingot size and the reduction it gives, within 24 hours on a working day. Ask for a sample EN 10204 3.1 MTC at the same time and read the grain size and carbide distribution lines on it.

4 : 1 minimum, every section
  • Grades on EFSThirteen of fourteen, across three families
  • Ultrasonic100% ultrasonic testing to SEP 1921 Class D/d or E/e
  • CertificateEN 10204 3.1 MTC on every batch, structure lines included

Or write to wonderful@fcstoolsteel.com · +86-18972782802 on WhatsApp. Mon–Fri 09:00–18:00 (GMT+8).